Federal Judge Agrees, Fannie Mae Foreclosure Could Violate U.S. Constitution

by in HPN Blog
  • Font size: Larger Smaller
  • Subscribe to this entry
  • Print

On May 7, 2012, Judge Robert J. Jonker of the United States District Court, Western District of Michigan dismissed Fannie Mae’s Motion for Summary Judgment in the case of Pablo Bocardo and Guadalupe Bocardo v. Select Portfolio Services and The Federal National Mortgage Association. (Docket # 1:12-cv-177) and is allowing this to go to trial.

Judge Jonker agreed with two points that the Bocardo’s attorney, Jason Jenkinson of the Northern Michigan Law Center argued.

Jenkinson argued that denying the Bocardos the right to contest the merits of their foreclosure after their redemption period would violate their due process rights under Article III of the U.S. Constitution. Judge Jonker agreed by stating, “…from my perspective, standing is an Article III jurisdictional issue. It deals with injury in fact first of all.  And I can’t imagine anybody better than the party that says they are entitled to lawful possession of the house because something was wrong with foreclosure process.”

During the investigation leading up to the lawsuit, Steve Dibert of MFI-Miami discovered a memo from Fannie Mae to their mortgage servicers stating Fannie Mae’s ownership interest.

 “This discovery allowed Jason to question whether the proper party in this matter foreclosed on the Bocardo’s home and if Fannie Mae has the authority to evict,” explained Dibert.

By denying The Defendants’ Motion to Dismiss, Judge Jonker ultimately forwarded the idea that further inquiry was needed to determine whether Michigan Statute MCL 600.3204 was violated by the alleged foreclosure and/or the improper attempt to evict

After the decision, Jenkinson commented that “it’s refreshing to see that someone is willing to look into how the foreclosure mills spearheaded by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac have been working overtime to throw people out of their homes.  Hopefully this will lead to more attempts by the banks to modify deserving homeowners.”
Bocardo Transcript 5-15-12

Original author: Steve Dibert
©Reposted with permission of MFI-Miami
Last modified on

Comments

Disclaimer: The information provided on HomePreservationNetwork.com is not legal advice, HomePreservationNetwork.com is not a lawyer referral service, and no attorney-client or confidential relationship is or should be formed by use of the site. The attorney listings on HomePreservationNetwork.com are paid attorney advertisements and do not in any way constitute a referral or endorsement by HomePreservationNetwork.com or any approved or authorized lawyer referral service. Your access of/to and use of this site is subject to additional Terms and Conditions.

Copyright 2012 HomePreservationNetwork
Site Developed by FLADDAP, INC.